Jerome (10 out of 10 ) Any script writen with the originato as one of the writers has got to be top shelf
Dennis (8 out of 10 ) Kudos to John Hurt and Ron Pearlman who had outstanding performances.
Randy Dutton (8 out of 10 ) Great job by Peter Briggs, the first writer on the movie (before Del Toro was ever attached). Del Toro should be ashamed for not giving him more kudos. Would that his other movies were as well written.
pyrovianthe hb fiend (10 out of 10 ) Dude hellboy rocks.