IndieBrit (10 out of 10 ) GREAT CAST....GREAT SCRIPT....GREAT SCORE AND THE SHATNER....WHAT MORE DOES A FILM NEED!!!!
Joe Phillips (8 out of 10 ) I would love to see another series with a new Capt. Kirk and crew. Perhaps another movie like Wrath of Khan, with Kirk battling a major war with the Klingons.
Lizziebeth-1 (10 out of 10 ) Still the best in the series, even counting the latest 2009 reboot!
Has heart, a wonderful narrative story, and finally depicts starships with Roddenberry's conceptualization as virtually submarines in space.
Probably the most honorable death on screen, desperately MOVING.
Kudos to previously "non-fan" Nick Meyer, who himself rebooted the TV show for films, saying "for a person who genuinely professed not to understand Star Trek, I unexpectedly discovered that my involvement...was among the most rewarding of my professional life so far". Star Trek still has the capacity to make a fan out of almost anybody. Sadly JJ.Abrams is yet to reveal if he has a heart in the right place.
Picard (10 out of 10 ) An outstanding movie in every way—and not just as a Star Trek movie. Fantastic script and story, great characters, superb visual effects (that still hold up today), first-rate editing and direction, and a brilliant score. 2009's Star Trek is absolutely nowhere near the class of Wrath of Khan.