jesse (10 out of 10 ) I loved it. It had everything: Kirk, Picard and McDowell. So cool, thank you Berman and Braga.
C (4 out of 10 ) Messy movie. Horrible plot holes (when did Worf and Riker forget how to modulate their shields? Why take Geordi in the first place? If the Nexus could take someone to any time and place, why didn't Picard try to stop Soran right when he first met him rather than waiting until the most dangerous moment possible?) and Kirk was practically unrecognizable.
Chris Wright (10 out of 10 ) I thought the dialog in this one was great, especially that of Picard, the Duras sisters, and Soren. I'd rate it as the best film (and thus script) of any of the eleven Trek movies. I mean, compared to the latest dross from Joss Weadon this is positively Shakespearean. "Time is the fire in which we burn", and all that. "Normal is what everyone else is and you are not". I just love this movie.