daniel (1 out of 10 ) An amusing take at making a Star Trek film like Star Wars, hey people different universes. What paramount should've done was to employ George "jar jar" Lucas in to make this schimozal of a movie why dont they make Will and Grace like Sex and the City it's 2 totally different shows but we'll just make one look like the other. I pay my hard earned cash to see that crap come on inspire me. Make me say wow instead these days we get one piece of garbage that looks like another. Pull your fingers out boys and make something original this movie sucked boss nass's gungan balls and that's a lot.
jesse (2 out of 10 ) Oh how this sucked, I am the biggest trekker ever and I can forgive most things. Insurrection sucked badly as well and I knew this would as soon as I saw Shinzon. Bad bad movie. A great space battle with some cool Romulan babe, the best part of the film. The rest I wish they never made this. Insurrection should have been the last, it wasn't so bad. First contact was 10 out of 10, but Braga and Berman must be exhausted and Spiner was trying to channel Leonard Nimoy in killing Data. It was not needed. I wrote a script if anyone cares to read it, I kill off Picard in the end of it with dignity and grace.
Star Trek fan (10 out of 10 ) Every Star Trek movie rocks. Change the point of view! THEY ARE THE BEST!
dharma (7 out of 10 ) Not the best star trek movie ever, but still not a bit boring. Data was killed because brent spiner couldn't/wouldn't play him any more. Sadly, the best parts were cut out, being not significant for the storyline. However the plot isn't that good, in contrast to this amazing battle and the overall atmosphere.